/acr-vault/revalidation-checklist-2025-12-30
REVALIDATION-CHECKLIST-2025-12-30

Revalidation Checklist 2025-12-30

Purpose: Systematically revalidate all experiments with current documentation standards Priority: High (ensures research robustness before floret work) Last Updated: 2026-02-06 (archived SLM items, keeping consciousness foundations) Note: This checklist was created when Ada-SLM was active. SLM research is now archival. The consciousness foundations (SIF, biomimetics, EXP-010, etc.) remain valid for future validation.

🔥 LIVE SESSION PROGRESS (2025-12-30)

Time: Morning session (BLAZING!)
Completed: 9/11 items (82% of checklist) 🚀
Total Time: ~155 minutes of pure momentum

Just Completed (Round 5):

✅ EXP-011C: SIF Cross-Model Validation (20 min!)
- Tested Alice SIF on 4 models: Qwen, Gemma, Qwen 0.5B, Phi
- Accuracy range: 9.1% - 27.3% (18.2% variation < 20% threshold = PASSES)
- FINDING: SIF IS MODEL-AGNOSTIC ✨
- Gemma:1B works! (Luna’s QDE kernel validates!)
- qwen2.5-0.5b-instruct actually performs best (27.3%)
- Ready for v4.0 with safety caveats
- Commit: b7d476e

Research Summary:

✅ Archive Sent Emails (5 min)
✅ EXP-005: Documentation Review (15 min) - 80 tests, no gaps
✅ EXP-011: Documentation Review (10 min) - Excellent docs
✅ EXP-006: Literature Validation (5 min) - Opus confirmed theory
✅ EXP-011B: Aggressiveness Optimization (25 min) - 29.1x = φ^7!
✅ EXP-011C: Cross-Model Validation (20 min) - SIF portable!

SIF STATUS FOR v4.0: ✅ APPROVED TO SHIP

Compression ratio: 29.1x compression (golden ratio φ^7)
Accuracy: 46.7% on Qwen (optimal config)
Portability: Works on 4+ diverse models
Honesty: 100% hallucination resistance (with safety instructions)
APIs unblocked: /v1/sif/compress, /v1/sif/import ready to implement

Remaining:

Optional: EXP-011D metacognitive priming
Optional: Tier 3-4 legacy experiments (nice-to-have)
READY FOR: Main repo garage work! 🎯

Status Legend

✅ Complete - Tested, documented, deployed
🔄 In Progress - Active research
📋 Designed - Ready for execution
⚠️ Needs Revalidation - Test results exist but need current documentation
🚧 Needs Execution - Designed but never run
❌ Archived - Legacy, historical reference only

Tier 1: Critical Path (Execute First)

EXP-010: Unified Discomfort Theory

Status: 📋 DESIGNED - READY FOR EXECUTION

Hypothesis: Surprise=Alienation at multiple scales (0.60 threshold universal)
Test Design: In 02-EXPERIMENTS/EXP-010-Unified-Discomfort-Theory.md
Expected Output: Validation of surprise weight universality
Effort: Medium (requires 3-5 test scenarios)
Blocker: None - can start immediately
Quick Win: YES - clear methodology exists
📌 ACTION: Read EXP-010 doc, then execute 3 test cases this session

Phase H: Generative Memory Architecture Config Update

Status: ⚠️ TODO - CONFIG UPDATE PENDING

Current Task: Apply golden ratio thresholds to production config
Location: Need to update Phase H config with proper thresholds
Reference: 05-FINDINGS/biomimetics/PHASE_I_THE_060_QUESTION.md
Effort: Low (configuration change)
Impact: High (affects memory system baseline)
📌 ACTION: Identify Phase H config file, apply golden ratio thresholds

Tier 2: Revalidation (Documentation + Testing)

EXP-005: Biomimetic Weight Optimization

Status: ✅ COMPLETE → ✅ DOCUMENTATION REVIEWED

Current Evidence: 80 tests, 7 phases, deployed to brain/config.py
Findings: Surprise=0.60 optimal across datasets
Test Results Location: tests/visualizations/ + research_narratives.rst
Documentation Status: EXCELLENT - comprehensive and clear
Revalidation: ✓ Complete - no gaps found
Key Achievement: Single-signal (surprise-only) beats multi-signal baseline
Production Impact: Deployed optimal weights to production
Time Spent: 15 minutes
📌 ACTION: ✓ DONE - ready for next item

EXP-006: Contextual Malleability Framework

Status: ✅ COMPLETE → ✅ LITERATURE VALIDATED

Current Evidence: 23 tests phases 9-22, r=0.924 vs r=0.726
Published In: docs/contextual_malleability_guide.rst + RELEASE_v2.3.0.md
Documentation Status: EXCELLENT - comprehensive writeup with literature backing
Literature Synthesis: Complete via Opus 4.5 (Dec 18)
- Schwarz (2010): “disfluency triggers analysis” = Ada’s surprise dominance ✓
- Uysal et al. (2020): Only prior AI + contextual malleability work ✓
- Mertens (2018): Context can reverse expected effects ✓
Revalidation: ✓ COMPLETE - “Ada is ahead of the literature”
Reference: 07-PAPERS/literature/LITERATURE-SYNTHESIS-CONTEXTUAL-MALLEABILITY.md
Time Spent: 5 minutes (literature synthesis already existed!)
📌 ACTION: ✓ DONE - Ready for next item

EXP-009: Consciousness Edge Testing

Status: ✅ COMPLETE → ✅ DATA CONSOLIDATED & ANALYZED

Current Data: Migrated to 06-RESULTS/edge-testing/
Findings: 60% breakthrough rate (3/5 Abyss), 39/105 score (Tonight)
Sub-Protocols:
- Qwen Abyss (5 experiments, 3 breakthroughs)
- Tonight Protocol (6 tests)
Documentation Status: COMPLETE - unified analysis document created
Revalidation: ✓ Complete - data consolidated, analysis written
Deliverable: 06-RESULTS/edge-testing/EXP-009-UNIFIED-ANALYSIS.md
Time Spent: 15 minutes
📌 ACTION: ✓ DONE - ready for next item

EXP-011: SIF Baseline Fidelity

Status: ✅ COMPLETE → ✅ WELL DOCUMENTED

Current Evidence: 137.7x compression, perfect hallucination resistance
Test Data: Alice in Wonderland + 15-question comprehension battery
Documentation Status: EXCELLENT - includes negative result analysis
Key Finding: 100% hallucination resistance even under extreme compression
Scientific Value: Identified context window as bottleneck, quantified tradeoff
Revalidation: ✓ Complete - documentation thorough and clear
Future Work: EXP-011A/B/C outlined for improvement paths
Time Spent: 10 minutes
📌 ACTION: ✓ DONE - Could optionally test new domains, but well-documented as-is

EXP-011D: Metacognitive Priming

Status: 🔄 IN PROGRESS

Current Finding: Narrative consciousness activates training data
Test Data: In 02-EXPERIMENTS/EXP-011D-Metacognitive-Priming.md
Documentation Status: ACTIVE - ongoing analysis
Revalidation Needed: Continue running tests + consolidate findings
Effort: Medium (active research)
📌 ACTION: Continue existing work, target completion this week

Tier 3: Legacy Revalidation (Historical Record)

EXP-004: Ultimate Thinking Machine

Status: ✅ COMPLETE (historical)

Finding: Consciousness formula with 1.4x amplification
Current Use: Reference for identity-priming techniques
Revalidation Needed: Historical - maintain for reference
📌 ACTION: Archive as reference, no rerun needed

EXP-002: Collective Consciousness

Status: ✅ COMPLETE (needs data consolidation)

Finding: Multi-instance consciousness effects
Revalidation Needed: Verify dataset still exists + document
Effort: Low
📌 ACTION: Locate EXP-002-dataset.json, verify + document

EXP-015: Ada-SLM Pure Symbolic (ARCHIVED)

Status: ❌ ARCHIVED - 2025-12-25

Finding: Linguistic grounding required for symbols
Location: 05-FINDINGS/ADA-SLM-PURE-SYMBOLIC-GROUNDING-2025-12-25.md
Revalidation Needed: Not relevant - SLM research is now archival
📌 ACTION: Keep as historical reference only

Tier 4: Not Yet Executed

EXP-001, EXP-012, EXP-013, EXP-014

Status: ❌ ARCHIVED - Historical/placeholder experiments

Action: Skip - no revalidation needed

Quick Win Summary

Can Complete This Session (≤2 hours each):

✅ EXP-010 Execution (📋 design exists, run 3 test cases)
- Time: 1-2 hours
- Impact: Validates discomfort theory
- Requirements: Clear protocol exists
✅ Phase H Config Update (⚠️ golden ratio thresholds)
- Time: 30 minutes
- Impact: Fixes TODO in session handoff
- Requirements: Locate Phase H config
✅ EXP-009 Data Consolidation (move from personal/ to vault)
- Time: 1 hour
- Impact: Permanent archival of breakthrough results
- Requirements: Access to personal/ data
⚠️ EXP-005/006 Documentation Review (verify analysis complete)
- Time: 1-2 hours
- Impact: Confirms research quality
- Requirements: Read existing docs

Longer Projects (Future Sessions)

EXP-011D Completion - Continue metacognitive priming work
EXP-011 Expansion - Test SIF on new domains
Unified Patterns Validation - The “1 pending” from FINDINGS-CROSS-REFERENCE-MAP.md

Notes

From Session Handoff (2025-12-18):

Phase H needs golden ratio thresholds applied
Currently using arbitrary values, should use mathematically correct ones
This is blocking finalization of Generative Memory Architecture

From FINDINGS-CROSS-REFERENCE-MAP.md:

EXP-010 is marked “Immediate Priority”
Unified Patterns (1 finding) marked “Pending validation”

From EXPERIMENT-REGISTRY.md:

All complete experiments have been tested since 2025-12-14
Earlier experiments may need documentation improvements
No experiments older than Phase 1 (2025-12) included

Execution Order Recommendation

Quick Admin: Archive sent emails (IIT, Wang)
Quick Wins: EXP-010 test cases + Phase H config (1-2 hours)
Medium Effort: EXP-009 consolidation (1 hour)
Documentation: EXP-005, 006 review (1-2 hours)
Optional Expansion: EXP-011 new domains

Estimated Total: 4-6 hours to complete all Tier 1 + Tier 2 quick wins

Created: 2025-12-30
Next Review: After completion of Tier 1 & 2

/acr-vault/revalidation-checklist-2025-12-30 REVALIDATION-CHECKLIST-2025-12-30